Why Metal Roofing vs Shingles: The Ultimate Guide for Homeowners.

09/12/23 | Roofing

You need a new roof for your home. You may wonder if metal roofing or shingles are better. Both have good and bad points. But which one suits your needs and preferences? In this article, we will compare metal roofing vs shingles. We will look at their longevity, durability, energy efficiency, material types, cost of metal roof vs shingle, maintenance, and repair. We will also give you some tips on how to pick the best roofing option for your home.

metal roof vs shingles

Longevity and Durability.

You need to think about how long the roof will last and how well it can handle the weather when you choose a roof. Metal roofing is better than shingles in this way.

Metal Roof vs Shingles Life Expectancy

Some estimates say metal roofs can last 40-70 years. This depends on the type and quality of the metal. This is much longer than asphalt shingles. They usually last 20-25 years. Other types of shingles, like wood or slate, may last longer. But they cost more and need more care.

Wind Resistance

You also need to think about how well the roof can stand strong winds. This is important in areas with hurricanes. Good metal roofing materials can handle wind speeds up to 140 miles per hour. This is much higher than the usual wind resistance of shingles. Metal roofs are also more secure. They do not blow off or curl up in high winds. They are attached to the roof deck with screws or nails.

Energy Efficiency

Metal roofing is energy efficient. It can help you save money on cooling costs. It reflects the sun’s rays and reduces the heat that goes into your home.

Cooling Cost Savings

Metal roofing materials that are energy efficient can bounce back up to 66% of the sun’s rays. This can save homeowners up to 40% in energy costs every year, according to some estimates. This is because metal roofs can make the roof surface cooler by up to 100°F than asphalt shingles. This means your attic and your home get less heat, and you need less air conditioning.

Material Types and Costs

You need to think about the type and the cost of metal roof vs shingle when you choose a roof. Metal roofing and shingles have different styles, colors, and qualities. Each one has good and bad points.

Material Preference

Aluminum is one of the most popular types of metal roofing. People in Florida use it a lot because it does not get damaged by salt. But aluminum can cost up to 2.5 times more than steel, which is another common type of metal roofing. Steel is stronger and safer than aluminum, but it can rust if you do not coat or paint it well.

Other types of metal roofing are copper, zinc, and stainless steel. They cost more but they also look nicer and more unique.

Shingles have different types too, such as asphalt, wood, slate, tile, and composite. Asphalt shingles are the most common and cheap type of shingles, but they also last the shortest and use the most energy. Wood shingles look natural and pretty, but they can rot, crack, or burn easily. Slate and tile shingles last longer and are stronger, but they are also heavier and more expensive. Composite shingles are made from fake materials that look like real materials, but they may not last long or be good for the environment.

Recycled Content

You also need to think about how the roofing material affects the environment. Many metal roofing materials have up to 95% recycled content, which makes them more eco-friendly than other roofing materials. You can also recycle metal roofs when they are old, which reduces waste and saves space. Shingles, on the other hand, are mostly made from oil-based products that do not break down or recycle. Shingles also make the air dirty by releasing harmful chemicals when people make or install them.

Maintenance and Repair

Another factor to consider when choosing a roof is how much maintenance and repair it will require over time. Metal roofs have a lower maintenance requirement than shingles, but they also have some drawbacks.

Lower Maintenance

Metal roofs need less maintenance than asphalt shingle roofs. You can save up to 60% over the roof’s lifespan. Metal roofs do not crack, curl, or get worse as shingles do. They also do not grow mold or algae. Metal roofs do not need cleaning or resealing like shingles do.

But metal roofs still need some maintenance. You need to check them regularly for damage, such as dents, scratches, or rust. You need to fix them quickly if they get hit by hail, branches, or other things. Metal roofs can also make noise when it rains or hails. This may annoy some homeowners.

Metal Roof vs Shingle: Which One is More Cost-Effective?

You may wonder if a metal roof or shingle is more cost-effective for your home. Both options have pros and cons. You may choose one or the other based on your budget, design preferences, and project size and complexity. In this section, we will compare the cost of metal roof vs shingle. We will also talk about some factors that can change the final price.

Initial Cost

The initial cost is one of the most obvious differences between metal roof and shingle. Metal roofs usually cost more than shingle. It needs more specialized materials and labor to install. Home Guide says a metal roof costs $5 to $16 per square foot installed. An asphalt shingle roof costs $3 to $5 per square foot installed. This means a metal roof can cost two to three times more than a shingle roof for the same size and complexity.

But the initial cost of a metal roof can change based on the type of metal you choose. There are different kinds of metal roofing materials. They are aluminum, tin, zinc, steel, and copper. Each one has its own pros and cons. For example, aluminum is light and recyclable, but not as strong as steel. Copper looks nice and lasts long, but it is very expensive and easy to steal. Forbes gives a helpful comparison of the pros and cons of different metal roofing materials.


As you can see, there are many factors to consider when choosing between metal roofing vs shingles. Both options have their pros and cons, and the best choice for your home depends on your budget, preferences, and needs. To make an informed decision, you should consult a professional roofing contractor who can assess your roof and provide you with a free estimate. A roofing contractor can also help you choose the best type, style, and color of roofing material for your home.

Top articles

Call Us