Why Metal Roofing vs Shingles: What You Need to Know Before You Choose.

09/7/23 | Roofing

Why metal roofing vs shingles? Are you looking for a new roof or thinking of replacing your old one? And don’t know if you should Choose Shingles or Metal Roof?

You may wonder which roofing material suits your home best. Metal roofing and roofing shingles are two of the most popular options. They have their advantages and disadvantages. You should consider your needs, preferences, and budget before you make a decision. In this article, we will compare these two types of roofing materials. We will look at their appearance, durability, cost, lifespan, environmental impact, and maintenance. We will also give you some tips on how to choose the right roofing material for your home.


When you choose a roofing material, you might want to think about how it will look on your home. You can find metal roofing and roofing shingles in many styles and colors. They can match different architectural designs and personal tastes.

Metal roofing is made of large flat sheets that have different folds, such as corrugated, standing seam, or flat seam. You can also get metal tiles or shingles that look like other materials, such as wood, slate, or clay. You can paint or coat metal roofing with different finishes to make it look better and last longer. Metal roofing has some advantages for appearance:

  • The type and color of metal can give your roof a modern, sleek, or rustic look.
  • Your roof can reflect sunlight and create interesting effects with different angles and lighting.
  • You can customize metal roofing to fit any shape or size of roof.

Roofing shingles are usually made of asphalt, which is a mix of organic or fiberglass materials and mineral granules. You nail roofing shingles onto the roof deck in layers that overlap. You can also get roofing shingles that look like other materials, such as wood shakes, slate tiles, or ceramic tiles. Roofing shingles have some advantages for appearance:

  • The type and color of shingles can give your roof a traditional, classic, or cozy look.
  • Your roof can have more depth and texture with different shapes and patterns of shingles.
  • Your roof can blend in with the surrounding environment and neighborhood.


How durable a roofing material is might be another important factor for you. Durability means how well a roofing material can handle different weather conditions, such as rain, snow, hail, wind, heat, cold, and UV rays. It also affects how often you need to repair or replace a roofing material. 

Metal roofing is usually more durable than roofing shingles. It can handle fire, water, hail, wind, and corrosion better. It does not crack or absorb moisture when the temperature changes. It can also take more snow and wind than roofing shingles. But metal roofing has some disadvantages for durability:

  • Hail or falling branches can dent or scratch it.
  • It can make noise or leak if it expands or contracts due to heat and cold and is not installed properly.
  • It can lose its color or rust over time if you do not coat or paint it properly.

Roofing shingles are less durable than metal roofing. Sunlight, moisture, heat, cold, and algae can make them worse. They can also curl, crack, or lose granules as they get older or face the weather. Hail or wind can damage them more than metal roofing. But roofing shingles have some advantages for durability:

  • They can make your roof quieter by absorbing sound from rain or wind.
  • They can keep your roof cooler or warmer by providing better insulation and ventilation.
  • You can fix or replace them easily if they get damaged.


You might also want to think about how long a roofing material can last before you need to replace it. This is called lifespan.

Metal roofing lasts longer than roofing shingles. Depending on the type and quality of metal, it can last up to 40 to 70 years or more. It also has longer warranties, usually from 30 to 50 years. You can recycle or reuse metal roofing when it is old, which is good for the environment.

Roofing shingles do not last as long as metal roofing. They can last up to 10 to 20 years or more, depending on the type and quality of shingles. They have shorter warranties, usually from 15 to 25 years. It is hard to recycle or reuse roofing shingles when they are old, which is bad for the environment.

Environmental Impact

Environmental impact is another significant factor that you might consider when choosing a roofing material. Environmental impact refers to how a roofing material affects the environment in terms of energy consumption, greenhouse gas emissions, waste generation, and resource depletion.

Metal roofing has a lower environmental impact than roofing shingles. Metal roofing is more energy-efficient than roofing shingles due to its higher reflectivity and emissivity, which reduce the heat gain and loss of the roof. Metal roofing is also more eco-friendly than roofing shingles due to its higher recyclability and reusability, which reduce the need for new materials and landfill space. Metal roofing is also made from more renewable and abundant resources than roofing shingles, such as steel, aluminum, or copper.

Roofing shingles have a higher environmental impact than metal roofing. Roofing shingles are less energy-efficient than metal roofing due to their lower reflectivity and emissivity, which increase the heat gain and loss of the roof. Roofing shingles are also less eco-friendly than metal roofing due to their lower recyclability and reusability, which increase the demand for new materials and landfill space. Roofing shingles are also made from more non-renewable and scarce resources than metal roofing, such as asphalt, fiberglass, or petroleum.


How much you need to take care of your roof is another important factor for you. This is called maintenance. It includes how much time, effort, and money you spend on keeping your roof in good shape.

Metal roofing is easier to maintain than roofing shingles. You do not need to clean, paint, or seal it regularly like roofing shingles. You also do not need to inspect, repair, or replace it often like roofing shingles. You only need to check it sometimes for leaks, dents, scratches, or corrosion, and fix them if needed.

Roofing shingles are harder to maintain than metal roofing. You need to clean, paint, or seal them regularly to keep dirt, algae, mold, or stains away. You also need to inspect, repair, or replace them often to avoid curling, cracking, or granule loss. You need to be more careful when you install or remove them to prevent damage or injury.

How to Choose Shingles or Metal Roof

You have learned how metal roofing and roofing shingles differ in appearance, durability, cost, lifespan, environmental impact, and maintenance. But how do you choose the best one for your home? These tips will help you make an informed decision:

  • Climate: Metal roofing is better for areas with extreme weather, such as heavy rain, snow, hail, wind, heat, or cold. It resists and withstands these conditions more than roofing shingles. Roofing shingles are better for areas with mild weather, such as moderate rain, snow, wind, heat, or cold. They cost less and are easier to install than metal roofing.
  • Budget: Roofing shingles are cheaper per square foot and save you money on the initial installation. Metal roofing lasts longer and consumes less energy, saving you money on the long-term maintenance.
  • Style: Metal roofing offers a variety of colors and finishes, giving your home a modern, sleek, or rustic look. Roofing shingles offer a variety of shapes and patterns, giving your home a traditional, classic, or cozy look.
  • Eco-friendliness: Metal roofs are more eco-friendly than shingles, as they are made of recycled materials and can be recycled again and again. Shingles, on the other hand, are made of petroleum-based products and contribute to landfill waste.

Benefits of Metal Roof vs Shingles

You already know the pros and cons of shingles and metal roofs from this article. But which one is better for your home? That depends on your budget, preferences, and needs. Here are some more things to think about when you compare shingles and metal roofs:

  • Cost: Shingles cost less than metal roofs. You can save money on installation and maintenance with shingles. The average cost of a shingle roof is around $7,000 to $10,000. A metal roof costs at least several thousand dollars more.
  • Energy efficiency: Metal roofs save more energy than shingles. They reflect solar heat and lower your cooling costs by 10% to 25%. Shingles absorb heat and make your attic and home hotter.
  • Noise: Metal roofs are louder than shingles during storms. They make the sound of rain, hail, and wind louder. You can make them quieter by adding insulation or a solid layer under the metal panels. Shingles are quieter and reduce the noise of the weather.
  • Weight: Metal roofs are lighter than shingles. They weigh about 50 to 150 pounds per square (100 square feet). Shingles weigh about 200 to 400 pounds per square. Metal roofs put less pressure on the roof structure and you can install them over existing roofs without adding much weight.
  • Installation: Metal roofs are harder and more expensive to install. You need special tools, skills, and fasteners for them. There are also fewer contractors who can work with them. Shingles are easier and cheaper to install. You can use common tools and materials to nail or staple them onto the roof deck. There are also more contractors who know how to install them.

HD Roofing and Solar: Your Trusted Roofing Contractor

You need a reliable and professional roofing contractor to install your new roof or replace your old one. HD Roofing and Solar is the company you can trust. We have a license and insurance, and we have been serving the area for over 20 years. Our workmanship is quality, our pricing is competitive, and our customer service is excellent. We can handle any roofing project, big or small. We can install, repair, or replace your roof. We also install and maintain solar panels to help you save money and energy.

We use only the best roofing materials from reputable manufacturers. We can help you choose the right one for your home. We consider your needs, preferences, and budget. We also give you a free estimate and a warranty for your peace of mind. Whether you want metal roofing or roofing shingles, we can install it for you with skill and care.

If you want a trustworthy and experienced roofing contractor, contact HD Roofing and Solar today. We will schedule your free consultation and estimate. We look forward to hearing from you and serving you with excellence.

Top articles

Call Us